
The Editor Zambia
It must be difficult to be President Hakainde Hichilema.
On one hand, civil society organisations (CSOs) accuse him of shrinking democratic space and silencing dissenting voices.
On the other hand, some of those same organisations now want him to reprimand Zambians exercising their democratic right to advocate for the removal of presidential term limits.
The contradiction is staggering because it exposes a troubling attitude among some self-appointed guardians of democracy who appear to believe that freedom of expression belongs exclusively to those who share their political and constitutional preferences.
The latest controversy surrounding the third-term debate raises a fundamental question: Who gave these CSOs the authority to speak on behalf of all Zambians?
Civil society organisations are important participants in a democracy. They have every right to express their opinions, challenge government decisions, and advocate for constitutional reforms.
But they are not elected representatives of the people, and their positions should never be mistaken for the collective wishes of the Zambian population.
Ordinary citizens equally have the right to express their views, whether these concern presidential term limits, constitutional amendments, or the country’s political future.
Why, then, should citizens who are advocating for the removal of presidential term limits be treated differently from those opposing the proposal?
Democracy cannot operate on a selective principle where one group enjoys unlimited freedom to express its position while another is expected to remain silent.
More disturbing is the apparent expectation that President Hichilema should publicly reprimand citizens calling for constitutional change to demonstrate that he is not sponsoring the campaign.
But why must the President police the opinions of citizens to satisfy the suspicions of CSOs? Would such an intervention not constitute precisely the kind of interference with freedom of expression that these organisations have repeatedly accused his administration of promoting?
One cannot spend months accusing a President of suppressing dissent and then demand that he suppress another group of citizens simply because their views are inconvenient.
That is not the defence of democracy. It is hypocrisy dressed up as democratic activism.
If CSOs genuinely believe in freedom of expression, they must defend that freedom even when the opinions being expressed contradict their own convictions.
Their responsibility is to participate in the debate, present arguments, and persuade the public, not demand that State House silence their opponents.
There is also a fundamental distinction that must not be lost in this debate. Advocating for the removal of presidential term limits is not the same as removing those limits.
Constitutional change must follow the prescribed legal and democratic processes, including the participation of citizens and the relevant constitutional institutions.
Nobody is suggesting that constitutional safeguards should be bypassed. But neither should citizens be intimidated into abandoning a debate that has entered the public domain.
President Hichilema has repeatedly maintained that he is focused on governing and delivering development rather than allowing himself to be drawn into the third-term controversy. That position should be respected.
Ultimately, the decision on constitutional questions belongs to Zambians through the lawful constitutional process, not to a handful of organisations claiming an exclusive mandate to determine what the people should discuss.
CSOs must understand that they are stakeholders in democracy, not its proprietors. They cannot claim to champion freedom of expression while attempting to determine whose opinions deserve protection.
They cannot demand that the President tolerate criticism of his administration while insisting that he silence citizens whose political opinions they dislike.
It must indeed be difficult to be President Hichilema. Even when he keeps quiet, some demand that he speaks. When citizens speak, they demand that he silences them.
Perhaps the greatest test of democracy is not whether we protect opinions with which we agree but whether we can tolerate those with which we profoundly disagree.
Zambia belongs to all its citizens. Its democratic space must accommodate all lawful opinions, not just those endorsed by the loudest CSOs.