Advertisement
Follow the News Live on Our Social Networks

TREASON CASES CANNOT BE TREATED LIKE ORDINARY CRIMINAL MATTERS

The Editor Zambia

The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Gilbert Phiri, deserves support for reminding the High Court that detention periods in serious treason cases cannot be judged mechanically, without considering the gravity of the alleged offences, the complexity of investigations and the circumstances surrounding each case.

The argument that 90 days in detention is automatically unreasonable simply because the Anti-Terrorism Act provides for a 45-day limit risks, reducing a serious constitutional and national security question to a mere calculation of days on a calendar.

Advertisement

Treason is not an ordinary criminal allegation. It strikes at the very foundations of the State, its constitutional order, national security, and the stability of public institutions.

Investigations involving alleged attempts to undermine the constitutional order may require considerably more work than ordinary criminal investigations.

They can involve multiple suspects, electronic evidence, communication records, financial trails, security assessments, and the reconstruction of events involving several individuals.

It is therefore reasonable for the DPP to urge the court to consider the totality of the circumstances rather than adopt an inflexible approach that ignores the nature of the allegations.

The DPP’s reliance on previous treason cases, including The People v Njapau of 1967 and The People v Edward Jack Shamwana and 12 Others, is particularly significant.

These cases demonstrate that Zambia has a judicial history of treating treason proceedings with the seriousness they deserve. The DPP is right to remind the court that constitutional bail is not something that should be granted automatically merely because an accused person has spent a considerable period in custody.

There is, however, an important distinction between demanding that the law be respected and suggesting that every detention period beyond 45 days is necessarily unlawful.

The State’s position deserves a fair hearing, particularly where the prosecution argues that the circumstances and complexity of the investigations justify the time taken.

The defence has invoked Section 55 of the Anti-Terrorism Act, which provides for a 48-hour period before suspects are brought before court, subject to judicially approved extensions, with detention not exceeding 45 days.
That provision must certainly be considered by the court.

But its interpretation, application, and relationship with the constitutional provisions governing detention are matters for judicial determination, not political declarations.

What should concern Zambians is the attempt to turn this legal proceeding into a contest in which the seriousness of the allegations is overshadowed by sympathy for the accused or political considerations.

Brian Mundubile and the other 17 accused persons are entitled to their constitutional rights and the presumption of innocence. Equally, the State has a constitutional obligation to protect the country and ensure that allegations threatening national security are investigated thoroughly.

The DPP is not asking the court to abandon the law. He is presenting the State’s position and asking the judges to consider established judicial precedents alongside the circumstances of the present case.
That is precisely what the prosecution is supposed to do.

It would be dangerous for Zambia to establish a judicial culture in which the gravity of an alleged offence becomes secondary to the length of time an investigation takes, regardless of its complexity.

Equally, national security must never become a convenient excuse for disregarding statutory safeguards.

The three judges must, therefore, strike the appropriate balance between individual liberty and the collective security of the nation.

Ultimately, the question is not whether 90 days sounds excessive in isolation. It is whether the detention and the conduct of the investigations are legally justified under the applicable law and constitutional protections.

Zambia must protect the rights of suspects without weakening the institutions responsible for defending its constitutional order.

That is the balance the DPP is asking the High Court to uphold, and his arguments deserve serious consideration.

Add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement