
The Editor Zambia
Amnesty International must be reminded that Zambia is a sovereign country governed by its Constitution and laws and not an extension of the international human rights organisation’s offices in London or elsewhere.
Its latest demand that President Hakainde Hichilema immediately release 18 opposition figures facing treason charges raises serious questions about the organisation’s objectivity, methodology, and apparent appetite for interfering in Zambia’s domestic affairs.
In an urgent action appeal dated November 17, 2026, Amnesty International has called on President Hichilema to release Brian Mundubile, Makebi Zulu and 16 others, arguing that they are being targeted for exercising their political rights and expressing opposing views.
But who appointed Amnesty International as Zambia’s prosecutor, judge, and constitutional authority? At what point did an international advocacy organisation acquire the power to determine who is innocent or guilty in a matter that is before the country’s judicial system?
The organisation’s position is particularly troubling because it appears to have reached its conclusions before the legal process has run its course.
It describes the detention as arbitrary and politically motivated while demanding that prosecution be terminated. Yet the very purpose of criminal proceedings is to establish the facts, examine evidence, and determine whether allegations can be sustained.
Nobody should be above the law, regardless of political affiliation. Equally, nobody should be condemned without due process.
If there are allegations of torture, denial of legal representation, or violations of detention procedures, these must be independently investigated and addressed.
However, allegations must not automatically be presented as established facts.
More concerning is that this is not the first time Amnesty International has positioned itself at the centre of Zambia’s political discourse.
Even before the August 2026 general elections, the organisation published a briefing portraying Zambia as experiencing shrinking civic space and restrictions on freedoms of expression, association, and peaceful assembly.
That intervention deserves scrutiny. Why was Amnesty so eager to establish a negative narrative about Zambia ahead of an important democratic exercise?
Did it give sufficient attention to the country’s political and security circumstances, or was it more interested in amplifying allegations against the government?
An organisation that claims to defend universal human rights must demonstrate consistency, impartiality, and intellectual honesty.
Amnesty International has faced criticism in different parts of the world over allegations of selective reporting, double standards, and organisational controversies. It should, therefore, not expect its pronouncements on Zambia to be accepted as an unquestionable gospel.
There is also something fundamentally wrong with addressing demands for the release of accused persons directly to the President as though he should personally dictate the outcome of judicial proceedings.
Zambia has separate constitutional institutions. The police investigate, prosecutors prosecute and courts adjudicate. Respect for the independence of these institutions should be central to any genuine human rights campaign.
Amnesty cannot simultaneously demand respect for the rule of law and encourage an approach that risks undermining judicial processes.
Zambia welcomes international scrutiny, but scrutiny must be fair, informed, and balanced. Human rights are not the exclusive property of international organisations, nor should they become instruments for advancing particular political narratives.
Mundubile, Makebi Zulu, and the other accused persons are entitled to their constitutional rights. But they are also subject to the laws of Zambia.
Amnesty International must learn to distinguish between defending human rights and interfering in the administration of justice.
Zambia is a sovereign republic, not a country that requires permission from Amnesty International to enforce its laws.