Advertisement
Follow the News Live on Our Social Networks

LINDA KASONDE MUST UNDERSTAND THAT DEMOCRACY CANNOT EXIST WITHOUT SECURITY AND THE RULE OF LAW

The Editor Zambia

Chapter One Foundation leader
Linda Kasonde’s declaration that Zambia’s democracy is on trial following the police decision to advise two civil society organisations against holding planned marches on November 25 raises an important question: does democracy mean exercising constitutional freedoms without regard to public security, law and order, or does it require a delicate balance between individual rights and the collective safety of citizens?

While Kasonde and her associates are entitled to express their opinions on the contentious debate surrounding presidential term limits, they must equally appreciate that freedom of assembly is not a licence to disregard the responsibility of the State to protect lives, property and national security.

Advertisement

The Zambia Police Service did not single out organisations which are opposed to the proposed constitutional changes. Both Chapter One Foundation, which planned a march opposing the removal of presidential term limits, and the Zambia Youth Organisations Consortium, which intended to demonstrate in support of their removal, received the same advice.

This is an important distinction that Kasonde appears unwilling to acknowledge. If the intention were to silence critics of Government, why would the police also advise an organisation supporting a constitutional position associated with the ongoing national debate not to proceed?

The equal treatment of the two organisations suggests that the police decision was informed by considerations beyond political positions.

National security cannot be viewed through the narrow lens of whether a demonstration supports or opposes Government.

The responsibility of any government is first and foremost to protect its citizens. The Constitution guarantees fundamental freedoms, but it also recognises the need for limitations that are reasonably justifiable in a democratic society, including considerations of public safety, public order, and the rights of others.

Kasonde cannot selectively invoke constitutional provisions protecting freedom of assembly while appearing to diminish the constitutional responsibility of the State to maintain peace and security. The two obligations are not mutually exclusive. They must operate together.

It is equally misleading to suggest that the police exist merely to facilitate demonstrations without considering the circumstances under which they are organised.

Police officers must assess intelligence, potential security threats, competing public interests, and the capacity to maintain order before allowing large gatherings to proceed.

A proposed demonstration involving hundreds or potentially thousands of participants is not an insignificant undertaking.
It requires adequate security arrangements, traffic management, and protection of members of the public who may have no interest in the political or constitutional arguments being advanced.

Zambia has witnessed the consequences of political intolerance, violence, and the misuse of public gatherings. No responsible government should wait for disorder to occur before taking preventive measures.

Security management is about anticipating threats, not simply responding after lives and property have been lost.
Kasonde, as a lawyer and former Law Association of Zambia president, should be among those encouraging citizens to resolve constitutional disagreements through established legal and democratic institutions rather than creating an atmosphere of confrontation.

The debate over Article 106(3) is a constitutional matter of national importance. However, no constitutional debate is so urgent that it must be pursued through a demonstration at the expense of public peace.

There are other avenues for citizens to express their views, including submissions to Parliament, public consultations, petitions, media discussions, and litigation, where appropriate.

The suggestion that democracy is on trial simply because police have raised security concerns is therefore premature and unnecessarily alarmist.

Democracy is not measured by how many demonstrations take place on a particular day but by the strength of institutions, respect for the law, protection of citizens’ rights, and the ability to resolve disagreements peacefully.

Zambia’s democracy must protect the right to dissent, but it must equally protect the right of ordinary citizens to live, work, and go about their business without fear of political disturbances.

Linda Kasonde must understand that the State has a responsibility to protect everyone, including those who do not participate in political demonstrations. Freedom without responsibility can become an instrument of disorder.

The rule of law must apply to everyone, activists, and the government alike. Democracy cannot be reduced to the demands of civil society organisations, nor can national security be sacrificed to satisfy the political preferences of particular groups.

Protecting democracy also means protecting the peace that makes democracy possible.

Add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement